Relative Path Confusion

'Path traversal' or 'Directory traversal' is a well-known vulnerability in web applications, where an attacker can access sensitive files and directories outside the intended directory or root directory. It happens when the application uses user-controlled input without validating and sanitizing it properly. One of the types of path traversal vulnerability is called 'Relative Path Confusion.' This vulnerability allows an attacker to access files or directories outside the web application's root directory by exploiting a relative path traversal vulnerability.

This article will provide a step-by-step guide to fixing the 'Relative Path Confusion' vulnerability in web applications.

‍

Step 1: Identify the Vulnerable Code

Before fixing any vulnerability, it is essential to identify the affected code. To find the vulnerable code, review the report generated by the scanner, which should include the details of the vulnerable file, line number, and description of the vulnerability.

In the case of 'Relative Path Confusion,' the vulnerable code often involves user-controlled input concatenated with a path that is not properly validated, for example:

// Vulnerable code $file = $_GET['file']; $path = '/var/www/app/files/' . $file; readfile($path);

‍

In the above code, the file variable is taken from the user's input without proper validation, and it is concatenated with a fixed path. An attacker can manipulate this input to traverse the directory and access sensitive files outside the intended directory.

‍

Step 2: Sanitize the User-Controlled Input

The first step in fixing the vulnerability is to sanitize the user-controlled input. This can be achieved by validating the input against a whitelist of allowed characters and removing any unwanted characters. In PHP, the following function can be used to sanitize the input:

// Sanitize user input $file = $_GET['file']; $file = preg_replace('/[^a-zA-Z0-9]/', '', $file);

In the above code, the preg_replace() function removes any non-alphanumeric characters from the input. It is important to note that this is just an example and that input sanitization depends on the specific application's requirements.

‍

Step 3: Validate the Input Path

After sanitizing the input, it is essential to validate the path before concatenating it with the fixed path. The path should be validated against a whitelist of allowed characters and should not contain any parent directory references.

In PHP, the following function can be used to validate the path:

// Validate the input path $path = $_GET['path']; if (preg_match('/\.\./', $path)) { die('Invalid path'); }

In the above code, the preg_match() function checks if the input path contains any parent directory references (i.e., ".."). If it does, the script terminates with an error message.

‍

Step 4: Use Absolute Path Instead of Relative Path

To prevent 'Relative Path Confusion' vulnerability, it is best practice to use an absolute path instead of a relative path. An absolute path starts from the root directory and includes the complete path to the file.

In PHP, the following function can be used to convert a relative path to an absolute path:

// Convert relative path to absolute path $file = $_GET['file']; $abs_path = realpath('/var/www/app/files/' . $file); if (strpos($abs_path, '/var/www/app/files/') !== 0) { die('Invalid path'); } readfile($abs_path);

In the above code, the realpath() function converts the relative path to an absolute path, and the strpos() function checks if the resulting path starts with the intended directory. If it does not, the script terminates with an error message.

‍

Step 5: Use chroot Jail

Another way to prevent 'Relative Path Confusion' vulnerability is to use a chroot jail. A chroot jail is a method of separating a process and its children from the rest of the system. It allows an application to run in a restricted environment with limited access to the file system.

In PHP, the chroot() function can be used to create a chroot jail. The following example demonstrates how to create a chroot jail and read a file from within the jail:

// Create a chroot jail chroot('/var/www/app/jail'); chdir('/'); // Read a file from within the jail $file = $_GET['file']; readfile('/files/' . $file);

In the above code, the chroot() function creates a chroot jail in the "/var/www/app/jail" directory. The chdir() function changes the current directory to the root of the jail. The readfile() function reads a file from within the jail by specifying the absolute path "/files/" concatenated with the user-controlled input.

‍

Step 6: Restrict Access to Sensitive Files

In addition to the previous steps, it is also important to restrict access to sensitive files and directories. This can be achieved by using file permissions or access control mechanisms.

For example, in Linux systems, file permissions can be used to restrict access to files and directories. The following command can be used to set the permissions of a file:

chmod 600 /var/www/app/files/sensitive.txt

In the above command, the chmod command sets the permissions of the file "sensitive.txt" to 600, which means that only the owner of the file can read and write to it.

‍

Conclusion:

'Relative Path Confusion' vulnerability can be a serious security issue in web applications. It allows an attacker to access sensitive files and directories outside the intended directory. To prevent this vulnerability, it is important to sanitize and validate user-controlled input, use absolute paths instead of relative paths, use chroot jails, and restrict access to sensitive files and directories.

By following the steps outlined in this article, you can effectively prevent 'Relative Path Confusion' vulnerability in your web application and improve its overall security. However, it is important to keep in mind that security is an ongoing process, and it requires constant attention and maintenance. Regularly reviewing and testing your application for vulnerabilities is crucial to ensure its security.

‍